When I saw pizza rustica on the Tuesdays With Dorie: Baking with Julia schedule I was excited. I love pizza! However, I’ve learned since then that pizza rustica is a little more like a quiche than pizza. I enjoyed learning about a new dish and practicing some more pie making skills. I’m not sure this dish is up my alley though.
Pizza rustica is a savory Italian pie with a buttery sugar dough. You can find the recipe at this week’s hosts: Capital Region Dining and The Place They Call Home. This recipe is made in a 9 inch pie pan which is somewhat unusual compared to the other pizza rustica recipes I’ve come across.
I used my food processor to make the dough. I thought it was extremely easy to make and work with. I let mine chill in the refrigerator for a bit even though the recipe didn’t call for it.
I stuck pretty close to the original recipe for the filling. It calls for ricotta, eggs, Pecorino Romano, mozzarella, prosciutto, parsley, and black pepper. I typically avoid pork simply because I don’t enjoy the taste. So I subbed the more family-pleasing pepperoni for the prosciutto.
I’m still learning a lot about rolling out and transferring dough. Pie dough has always intimidated me. So I have just plain avoided making pies for the most part. I want that to change though! Some useful tips that have been helpful as I’ve ventured into the pie-making arena:
- keep the dough moving as you roll it
- use flour as needed to help prevent the dough from sticking
- don’t push your rolling pin all the way off the edges and stop a little beforehand. This helps the edges from becoming too thin.
No problems with the pizza rustica dough. After rolling the crust, I folded it onto itself and transferred it to my pyrex pie plate.
This recipe was a great excuse to buy another kitchen gadget–a fluted pastry cutter! So I cut 12 strips for the top and layered 6 each way in a criss-cross fashion.
I baked the pizza rustica at 350 degrees F. for about 40 minutes. Since this is a dish eaten at room temperature, I let it sit for a few hours before I served it as a first course with dinner.
My verdict: this is not going into my regular rotation of recipes. While I loved the ease and flavor of the sweet crust I was not a fan of the savory baked ricotta filling. Something about the texture was off-putting to me. Maybe I disliked eating it at room temperature. I thought it was much better the next day when I warmed it up.
It was an interesting baking adventure just the same! Have you ever made or eaten pizza rustica before? Am I the only one to not absolutely love it? What do you think of this dish?


Adoring all British I took this as a pie with Italian ingredients
Yours looks very pretty.
Ulrike @Küchenlatein
thank you!
I think that seems to be the general consensus on this recipe: great dough for use in another pie!
Glad to know I’m not the only one with pie dough issues! Hopefully by the end of the book we’ll all have pies mastered
Yes, I have high hopes I will master pies! This dough was so easy I am feeling more confident already
Make the dough, change the filling! Good pie crust is good pie crust and yours turned out beautifully! I’ve never had pizza rustica… good to know it’s not one for the list though. Thanks!
A lot of the group did enjoy it. It was just not my taste I suppose. That’s why I love that the baking group challenges me to make recipes I might pass on. Then I would not have found this great crust!!
Looks great! Love the use of the fluted pastry cutter. I’m a gadget lover. Will be getting this gadget…really adds to the visual appeal.
~ Carmen
http://bakingismyzen.wordpress.com/2012/04/03/twd-baking-with-julia-pizza-rustica/
Sounds very rich.
It is! That’s a lot of cheese
I think you should definitely have kudos for making your own pie crust! That takes time & effort, plus homemade always tastes better! Never tried this before but one thing I know, you make a mean tart!!!
Thanks. I surely do feel more comfortable with tart shells!
Your lattice top looks so pretty! I subbed out the prosciutto too but I used bacon. I think pepperoni would b really good and add a little kick. I’ll try that next time!
Thanks, I am think a veggie version myself if I make it again.
Very nice job. I think the name “pizza” was misleading but I enjoyed the flavor all the same!
True, maybe “sweet & savory ricotta meat pie” would work better.
I was a little put off by the sweetness of the dough. It seemed like every other bite made me change my mind: it’s fine; too sweet; it’s fine; too sweet.
I probably will never make this again, but like folks have noted, the pie dough would be interesting with something else as the filling. Yours turned out beautifully!
Thanks! That’s funny how you described eating it. I was telling myself the same thing!
Yay for new kitchen toys! Your pizza rustica looks great!
Thanks! I need to find more room for my gadget collection
Your lattice top was beautiful! I did enjoy this, but it was VERY rich. My kids LOVED the sweet crust:)
My daughter actually ate the crust but most picked at the filling. The crust was the star.
I am Italian-American and Pizza Rustica is an acquired taste. It can be very, very dense; but I always love food that is made in advance and can be served at room temperature. Perhaps if you don’t sweeten the dough it might be more palatable.
Buona Pasqua, Lisa
Thanks for sharing. It would be very convenient dish for a party.
This is definitely an acquired taste. Very, very dense; but love the fact that it is made in advance and can be served at room temperature. Maybe try the crust without making it sweet.
Buona Pasqua
I was so excited to buy another kitchen gadget for this recipe too!
We weren’t crazy about pizza rustica either, but we all got a great crust recipe out of it! Looks great!
Thanks! Hurray for a tasty crust and fun kitchen tools!
Yours looks good! My boys decided to call it a piezza since it looked more like a pie than a pizza.
Thanks, that’s funny
Thanks for stopping by at my blog. I applaud you for trying to get more comfortable with pie dough. It’s one of the few things in baking that doesn’t actually scare me. I’ve practiced a lot though. This dough did give me trouble. It was so soft and tore easily, but I seem to be in the minority. I did like the way it tasted, so I’m not sure what’s up. Your pie is a beauty!
It looks beautiful and I quite liked the idea of it but I think the room temperature would put me off, I’d rather have it piping hot, as you suggested.
Thanks! I do think I prefer it hot.
Your pie skills are certainly looking stellar in this case! I too have trepidations with pie doughs & crusts, but TWD & FFWD recipes & cooks are teaching me so much-thank you for your comments.
Thank you! That’s why I love this group. Everyone is teaching me a ton and pushing me outside of my comfort zone.
I agree with you, it looks more like a quiche than a pizza and I would prefer something like this served warmed rather than at room temperature. Having said that, I think your pizza rustica looks beautiful and your crust is perfect.
Thank you so much!
Your lattice top looks lovely, and yes definitely more of a quiche.
you are certainly not alone in not loving it but not hating it either
we are all seemingly having the same experience. My hubby and I want to try it with different ingredients but still shy from making it again so soon… LOL!
Funny – I like the filling at really didn’t think the crust went well with it! I have to get flutted pastery cutter. Your pie is beautiful.
Pie dough and I are still coming to terms with each other – but I think by the end of this, we should be on much better terms
I liked the crust, I just think I would like it better with something else.
We really liked it but we also weren’t expecting a lot. I am excited to try it with some other things added in, like mushrooms and such. Yours looks delicious.
I agree it was good.. just not convinced to come back to it though!! yours worked out really well!!
The lattice looks great! The pepperoni instead of prosciutto sounds like it might have been the extra “bit” that was missing…
I like the lattice work! Looks pretty enough to eat!
I agree this tasted better the next day warmed up. I put some away in the freezer since it was too rich to eat all at once. Nice job!
This pie definitely improves with age! Yours is lovely.
I have to admit – I am also with pie dough issues
The pie crust was ok for me but I was not that impressed… I agree with you that it was really easy to roll though.
I make something similar but I don’t know if it’s a pizza rustica. It’s a savory pie with eggs and cheese but there’s also roasted cauliflower & carmelized onion. I put dijon in with the egg/cheese mixture and it’s delicious!
The result looks so beautiful and tempting! Yet, I didn’t expect it will come from someone who felt intimidated by ‘pie crusts/dough’
To let you know I have the same problem and feeling with making pie dough/crust. I once tried making apple pie – forgot what site I got the recipe from. I simply tried it because my husband loves apple pie, plus I felt like answering the challenge of making it. Turned out it was okay with the filling, but disaster with the crust! lol.. I’d like to give it another shot though!
Lovely recipe!
you did a nice job with the pastry dough. awesome. What kind of camera do you use?
Thank you. I use a Nikon S8200. I am trying to learn the basics to improve my photos.